Since the inception of the Sugarcreek Borough Police Department, there have been 58 officers employed by the department, while eight remain on the force.

Chief of Police Matthew R. Carlson	Lieutenant Ryan D. Ashbaugh
Lieutenant Darin L. Baker	Senior Patrolman Frank D. Heller
Patrolman Joe Highfield	Patrolman Robert E. Martz Jr.
Patrolman Jarrod L. Deeter	Patrolman William McDevitt IV

Patrolman James Harrah

Terri Lowry, Pat Jarzenske serve on the Sugarcreek Police Civil Service Commission.

Officer Darin Baker was one of the members of the Oil City National Guard who deployed to Iraq for Operation Iraqi Freedom. He returned to police duty in 2005 after his one year deployment.